The Top 5 Rules For Movie Remakes

This article was prompted by news that Sony is looking for writers to do a new version of the campy 1985 horror flick Fright Night, an idea that readers of Screen Rant might be surprised to hear I’m not against.

For the most part, I despise Hollywood’s habit of remaking past films. Sure sometimes it works (The Departed, Ocean’s 11, The Thomas Crown Affair, Scarface), but for the vast majority it doesn’t (Planet of the Apes, The Poseiden Adventure, The Pink Panther, Point of No Return, Sabrina, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, etc., etc., etc.), and is just a blatant and often creatively bankrupt attempt at cashing in on the name of some past, well-known movie.


So having said that, when is it okay to remake a film? If it’s done well, I don’t have a problem with remakes of original films that meet any of the following criteria:

1. Stories in the public domain that have already had multiple movie remakes done.

Movies based on classic stories like The Three Musketeers, Dracula, Frankenstein, etc. These have been remade so many times already that you can’t really logically argue against another one, and sometimes a newer version turns out to be quite good.

2. The original is terribly dated in either setting or pacing and style.

In this category you’ll find movies like Ocean’s 11 and The Thomas Crown Affair. I’ve watched both the original versions and the remakes and while I’m no fan of the seizure-inducing, quick-cut filming style used in so many movies today, the pacing in some movies from the late 60’s/early 70’s was so slow that it could put you in a coma.

3. The original is not terribly well known or beloved.

Let me start off by saying that there is a special place reserved in Hell for the person that ever gets a remake of Casablanca produced. Some movies should just be off limits. Period. Movies that are a part of the fabric of the history of cinema should just be left alone, if for no other reason than because they have withstood the test of time and are still considered excellent and extremely enjoyable today. In addition to Casablanca I would add It’s a Wonderful Life, 12 Angry Men, The Maltese Falcon (yes, I know the Humphrey Bogart version is a remake, but let’s leave it alone now, shall we?) and of course, Citizen Kane. There are many others, but you get the gist.

4. The remake does in fact bring something new while respecting the original.

Here we have movies like Cape Fear, The Magnificent Seven and The Thing. Each of these was a remake that brought something fresh to the original story, whether in concept or execution.

5. The original was basically pretty cheesy or tongue-in-check in tone and most folks wouldn’t care if it was remade.

Little Shop of Horrors and even Eight Legged Freaks as a new twist on the classic giant-ant movie Them. This is the category where I think a remake of Fright Night fits: It was pretty campy and didn’t take itself too seriously and while it was a fun movie, I don’t think it falls under “untouchable” status. In the right hands it could be quite good, but that’s certainly no guarantee.

So from now on when I rant against some remake, you’ll know that it doesn’t fall under any of the five rules listed above. 🙂

What do you think… are there any other criteria under which it’s ok to remake a movie?

Doctor Strange 2: All The Scarlet Witch Variants Who Could Appear

About The Author

Vic Holtreman (2188 Articles Published)

Vic Holtreman founded the popular movie news site back in 2003 – and, with the help of a talented editorial team, turned Screen Rant into one of the most-respected websites covering the film industry. Prior to starting Screen Rant, Vic had been employed as a door to door salesman, construction worker, car salesman, waiter, mechanical drafter, mechanical designer, system administrator and finally an SEO specialist (experience that became instrumental in Screen Rant’s success). Long before he started writing online, he has always been a huge Sci-Fi fan – starting with “The Twilight Zone” and “Outer Limits” when he was still too young for kindergarten, graduating to “Star Trek” reruns in the 70’s and of course fully initiated by the original “Star Wars.” He’s also a big comic book fan (and still buys them) and lover of superheros, action movies, and the occasional horror flick.

More From Vic Holtreman

Related Posts

Every Pokémon In Legends Arceus’ Pokédex

Pokémon Legends: Arceus's Hisui region is filled with regional variants and Pokémon evolutions. Here are all the available Pokémon in the Hisui Dex.

Will The Simpsons Movie 2 Ever Happen? Showrunner Talks Possible Sequel

Co-showrunner Al Jean reveals whether The Simpson movie 2 is in the works 15 years after the original film debuted to rave reviews.

Pokémon Scarlet & Violet: 10 Best Reddit Predictions About The Games

Not much information is known about Pokémon Scarlet and Violet, but fans have already been predicting what they expect in generation 9 on Reddit.

MCU: 10 Major Casting Rumors We Wish Were True

Everyone dreams of being a superhero but who would you like to see play one on the big screen? Here's a look at Marvel castings we wish were true.

10 Movies To Watch If You Love The Fighter

If you couldn't get enough of The Fighter, here are 10 other recommendations that are guaranteed to be dramatic knockouts

‘Castle’ Season 5, Episode 9: ‘Secret Santa’ Review – He’s Dead, Jim

Castle and Beckett investigate the death of a Santa Claus while navigating their first holiday season as an official couple in 'Castle' season 5, episode 9: 'Secret Santa.'

Game of Thrones: Night King Arrested by Norwegian Police

Game of Thrones' infamous Night King is arrested by the Trondheim police force in Norway, and accused of property damage and animal cruelty.

How Maguire, Garfield, & Holland’s Spider-Men Are Different

Tobey Maguire, Andrew Garfield, and Tom Holland have all played Spider-Man, and each channels a different side of Peter Parker in their movies.